Three Israeli hostages held by Hamas since 7 October 2023 have been released as part of ongoing negotiations. The individuals—Alexander Troufanov, Yair Horn, and Sagui Dekel-Chen—were kidnapped from Kibbutz Nir Oz during the initial Hamas attack.
Their release was marked by a carefully staged event orchestrated by Hamas, reinforcing its control over the Gaza Strip and psychological influence over Israeli society.
Hamas’ Psychological Strategy
Israeli President Isaac Herzog condemned the release event as a “despicable and cynical ceremony,” stating that the hostages were forced to endure a highly orchestrated spectacle before being handed over to the Red Cross. The ceremony, held in Khan Younis, was laden with Hamas propaganda, including banners rejecting any form of resettlement except in Jerusalem, and displays of captured Israeli weaponry.
Hamas deliberately shifts the location of each hostage release, demonstrating its ability to operate across the entire Gaza Strip and reinforcing its claim to territorial control. This latest handover was staged in Khan Younis, near the ruins of the former residence of Hamas leader Yahya Sinwar, underscoring the group’s continued influence despite ongoing Israeli military operations.
The event also featured images of key Hamas leaders killed in Israeli operations, while militants openly displayed Israeli-made assault rifles captured during the 7 October attacks. The move is part of a broader effort to exploit Israeli public opinion, manipulating the hostages’ return to sow further division and debate over the country’s approach to the conflict.
Reactions from Israel and the International Community
Defence Minister Israel Katz reaffirmed that Israel would continue working with the United States to secure the return of all remaining hostages while dismantling the “Palestinian terror threat.” The Hostages and Missing Families Forum noted that Monday marks 500 days since 73 hostages were taken and remain in Hamas captivity.
Meanwhile, Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s office thanked U.S. President Donald Trump for his “clear and unequivocal” support in facilitating hostage releases. Hamas, for its part, reiterated that no hostages would be released without negotiations, dismissing any possibility of unilateral gestures.
Russian state media has sought to claim credit for the release of Alexander Troufanov, citing his Russian citizenship. However, analysts widely agree that his return was solely part of Israel’s ongoing negotiations and not a result of Russian diplomatic efforts. Previous hostages with foreign citizenship, including French, Canadian, and American nationals, have been released under similar circumstances.
Hostages and Prisoner Exchanges
The release of these three hostages was secured in exchange for 369 Palestinian prisoners. Among them, 36 had been convicted of serious crimes, including orchestrating attacks resulting in multiple Israeli casualties. Reports indicate that five of the released prisoners required medical attention upon their return to Ramallah, with some suffering from chronic illnesses.
The wider implications of the exchange have sparked debate in Israel. While some view it as a necessary humanitarian effort, others argue that the escalating exchange rates—wherein Hamas demands increasing numbers of Palestinian prisoners per Israeli hostage—set a dangerous precedent.
Potential Second Phase and U.S. Involvement
The first phase of the hostage deal, which began on 19 January 2025, is set to last six weeks. Delays in implementing a second phase could prolong Israeli military operations in Gaza buffer zones and delay humanitarian reconstruction efforts. Hamas has signalled that it will demand international guarantees, likely from the U.S., before proceeding with additional releases.
U.S. President Donald Trump has continued advocating for resettlement plans for Gaza’s population, a stance that has drawn mixed reactions. Some analysts suggest that this is a strategic move to pressure Arab nations into addressing the longstanding Palestinian issue. Others argue that any plan for large-scale resettlement would face immense political and logistical challenges.
Future Scenarios
With at least one more planned hostage release under the current framework, Israel faces a critical decision: whether to advance towards a second phase that could see the full cessation of hostilities or to resume military operations.
Hamas is expected to demand stronger international guarantees, potentially from Washington, to ensure that Israel does not resume military actions after the hostages are freed. The U.S. administration’s role in this process will be crucial, as Israeli dependence on American diplomatic and military support remains significant.
As families in Israel welcome back their loved ones, and Palestinians celebrate the return of prisoners, the broader political and security implications of these exchanges remain at the forefront. The coming weeks will determine whether the conflict moves toward de-escalation or renewed escalation.
Image source: timesofisrael.com
Read also:
Israel-Hamas Prisoner Exchange Deal Faces Uncertainty Amid Key Dispute