The Birmingham Pub Bombing of 21st November 1974, when bombs exploded in two pubs, killed 21 people and injured 220. Attributed to the Provisional IRA, the atrocity remains “England’s biggest unsolved mass murder of the 20th century.”
Fifty years on, the families of the Birmingham pub bombing victims are intensifying their calls for a statutory public inquiry, as they continue their quest for answers and justice.
The blasts at the Mulberry Bush and Tavern in the Town pubs devastated families and left an indelible mark on the city. A third bomb, placed in a bank doorway, failed to detonate. The six men initially convicted of the attack—known as the Birmingham Six—had their convictions quashed in 1991 after it emerged they were victims of a grave miscarriage of justice. However, no one else has been convicted in connection with the bombings.
Calls for a Public Inquiry
Julie Hambleton, whose 18-year-old sister Maxine died in the attack on the Tavern in the Town, has been at the forefront of the campaign for a public inquiry. Speaking on behalf of the families, she urged Prime Minister Keir Starmer and the Home Secretary to act, warning that time is running out for the ageing relatives of the victims.
“It wears you down because we’re all getting older. Surely there could be no greater service for Keir Starmer and his home secretary than to give us a statutory public inquiry,” said Hambleton.
The families argue that a statutory inquiry could finally address unanswered questions about the attacks and the failure to bring those responsible to justice. The lack of closure continues to overshadow the lives of survivors and relatives of the victims, many of whom have died without receiving answers.
The Wider Context: Troubles Legacy
The Birmingham bombings occurred against the backdrop of the Troubles, a conflict that claimed 3,532 lives, including 1,840 civilians, between the late 1960s and the Good Friday Agreement of 1998. The Provisional IRA, Sinn Féin’s armed wing during the period, has long been linked to the Birmingham attack, but definitive evidence tying individuals to the bombings has remained elusive.
Meanwhile, debates over addressing the legacy of the Troubles continue to fuel controversy in the UK. Keir Starmer has signalled his opposition to the Northern Ireland Troubles (Legacy and Reconciliation) Act, which came into effect in September 2024. The legislation limits legal actions over past incidents, providing conditional immunity to individuals who cooperate with investigations. Critics argue the act undermines victims’ rights and favours those implicated in past atrocities.
Starmer, speaking on an LBC Radio call-in, reiterated his stance against the act, citing his experience with Northern Ireland’s complex legacy. “I’ve got quite a lot of knowledge and experience of the process in Northern Ireland and the history and the aftermath,” he said.
If repealed, the act’s removal could pave the way for prosecutions of British veterans who served during Operation Banner, the UK’s military campaign in Northern Ireland. This aspect has drawn ire from veterans’ advocates who claim it would unfairly target those who served the state while leaving former paramilitaries unpunished.
Screenshot
Former Veterans Minister Rt. Hon. Johnny Mercer has, in Parliament, asserted that fairness must underpin efforts to address the past. “I have only ever argued for fairness—and yes, that includes veterans who did the bidding of this House for the freedoms and privileges that Members on the Opposition Benches enjoy.”
The former Captain in 29 Commando Regiment, Royal Artillery, and a veteran of Operation Herrick, the war in Afghanistan, stated on December 5th: “Any veteran contacted by these inquiries and inquests who is unsure of their rights should contact me through existing veterans networks and I will connect them with experienced, pro bono legal and pastoral support.
“You are not on your own. There are hundreds of veterans affected by this – I am in touch with and have supported so many over the last decade, and I will do all I can for you too.”
Political Divisions
Starmer’s position has unsurprisingly drawn support from Sinn Féin, originally founded as the political wing of the Provisional IRA.
Sinn Féin welcomed the Labour leader’s opposition to the Legacy Act, seeing it as a step towards addressing past injustices.
However, critics argue that repealing the legislation could further politicise efforts to reconcile Northern Ireland’s history and disrupt the fragile balance established by the Good Friday Agreement.
For the Birmingham families, the political wrangling over Northern Ireland’s past is secondary to their core demand for truth and accountability. Their fight for a public inquiry highlights enduring questions over why no one has been brought to justice for the bombings, despite the quashing of the Birmingham Six convictions over 30 years ago.
A Continuing Struggle For Justice
On the 50th anniversary of the Birmingham bombings, the families’ campaign serves as a stark reminder of the enduring impact of unresolved atrocities. Julie Hambleton and other relatives argue that the government has a moral duty to prioritise their case, “It’s about justice and answers for the 21 who were killed and the hundreds who were injured,” she said. “We can’t let this remain an open wound.”
With time running out for many of the victims’ relatives, their calls for action resonate with a broader desire for truth, accountability, and closure in the face of one of Britain’s darkest chapters. Whether the government will heed their plea remains to be seen.
The author is a veteran of Operation Banner.
Main Image: On This Day Finding Dulcinea via Wikipedia.
